Underwater on Your Car Loan? The Chapter 13 Cramdown in 2026, the 910-Day Rule, and the Payment Cut That Keeps Your Car
If you owe more on your car than it is worth, a Chapter 13 cramdown can shrink the secured part to the car's value, turning the rest into unsecured debt. It works only when you bought the car more than 910 days before filing, and only while you keep paying the plan and keep the car insured.
For more plain-language explainers on everyday problems, see the Problem Solved channel.
- A car bought more than 910 days before a Chapter 13 filing can be crammed down; a car bought within 910 days cannot, and the full claim must be paid.
- The secured claim becomes the car's current replacement value, and the balance above that value becomes unsecured debt.
- Chapter 13 plans run three to five years, and the crammed-down claim is paid through the plan at a court-set interest rate.
- Under Till v. Saginaw, the cramdown interest rate starts from a prime rate plus an adjustment for risk.
- A mortgage secured only by a principal residence cannot be modified this way, so the cramdown is a car-loan tool, not a home-loan tool.
What a Cramdown Actually Does
A secured loan has two parts in bankruptcy, even though the lender sends one bill: the value of the car itself, and everything above that value, which is no better than an ordinary unsecured debt. A cramdown, the word lawyers use for the rule in section 1325 of the Bankruptcy Code, forces the lender to accept that split. The lender keeps a secured claim equal to what the car is worth today, the rest joins the unsecured debts a plan often pays only in part, and the lender keeps its lien until the plan is complete.
The 910-Day Rule That Decides Eligibility
One date controls the whole question: the day you bought the car. If more than 910 days, roughly two and a half years, passed between that purchase and your Chapter 13 filing, the cramdown is available. If you bought within 910 days before filing, a special paragraph in section 1325, often called the hanging paragraph, blocks the cramdown for a motor vehicle bought for personal use, and the plan must pay the lender's full claim. A filing made a few weeks too early can cost thousands of dollars of relief that a slightly later filing would have preserved.
The Math, Worked Out in Plain Numbers
Take a concrete example, framed only as an illustration. Suppose you owe $25,000 on a car now worth $16,000. After a cramdown, the secured claim is $16,000 and the remaining $9,000 becomes unsecured debt, because $25,000 minus $16,000 equals $9,000. The $16,000 is paid through the plan with court-set interest, while the $9,000 is paid at whatever percentage your plan pays unsecured creditors. The arithmetic is simple; proving the $16,000 value is the hard part, and valuation evidence decides more cramdown disputes than any legal argument.
Who Benefits From This — and Who Does Not
Drivers with an older car and a long loan benefit most: bought four years ago, still owing a large balance, in a model that lost value quickly, the gap between loan and value is exactly what a cramdown captures. Borrowers already in Chapter 13 for other debts benefit too, since adding the cramdown costs little extra effort. People who bought recently, owe little more than the car is worth, or need the car only a few more months gain far less, and should weigh the cost of bankruptcy itself before filing for the cramdown alone. Readers weighing the wider decision can compare the plan framework in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in 2026: The Repayment Plan, Keeping Your Home and Car, and Who Qualifies, and the cost of falling behind in Missed a Chapter 13 Payment in 2026? The Dismissal Clock, the Cure, and the 4 Ways to Keep Your Case Alive. Borrowers who cannot keep insurance on the car do not benefit at all, because the lender can seek permission to repossess despite the plan.
How to Ask for It, Step by Step
First, confirm the purchase date and count 910 days back from your planned filing date. Second, gather valuation evidence before you file: a written appraisal, dealer quotes, and comparable sales for the same year, make, and mileage. Third, file Chapter 13 and propose a plan stating the car's value, the secured amount, and the interest rate, with the balance listed as unsecured. Fourth, expect the lender to object if it values the car higher, and be ready for a valuation hearing where the judge weighs both sides' evidence. Fifth, once the plan is confirmed, pay the trustee on time and keep full insurance in force throughout.
The Costly Mistake to Avoid
The costliest mistake is filing before the 910 days have run. A borrower who files a month early locks in the full claim for the entire plan, and refiling later is rarely a clean fix, because a second filing brings its own complications with the automatic stay. The second mistake is treating confirmation as the finish line: missed payments or a lapse in insurance can lead to dismissal or to the lender asking the court to lift the stay, and either outcome returns the lender to its original rights. A cramdown rewards patience twice, waiting out the 910 days and seeing the plan through to discharge.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who benefits most from a car cramdown?
A borrower in Chapter 13 whose car was bought more than 910 days before filing and is now worth far less than the loan balance, because the secured claim drops to the car's current value and the rest becomes unsecured debt.
Who does not benefit from a cramdown?
A borrower who bought within 910 days before filing, because the hanging paragraph of section 1325 requires the full claim to be paid. A borrower who cannot keep up plan payments or insurance also gains little, since repossession ends the benefit.
How do I start a cramdown on my car loan?
File Chapter 13, then propose a plan listing the car's current value as the secured claim and the balance as unsecured, supported by an appraisal or comparable sales. If the lender objects, the bankruptcy judge decides the value at a hearing.
Can a cramdown cut my home mortgage too?
No. A mortgage secured only by your principal residence generally cannot be modified in Chapter 13, a separate protection for home lenders. The cramdown here applies to a car loan and to other debts without that protection.
What interest rate applies to the crammed-down claim?
Under Till v. Saginaw, the rate starts from a prime rate plus an adjustment for risk. The court fixes the rate in the plan, so the lender is paid the car's value plus that interest over the plan.
What happens if my Chapter 13 plan fails after a cramdown?
If the case is dismissed, the cramdown falls away and the lender's original rights return, including pursuing the full balance and repossessing the car. Only a completed plan and discharge make the reduced treatment permanent.
This article is general information, not legal or financial advice. Bankruptcy and disability rules turn on individual facts and deadlines; consider speaking with a qualified attorney about your situation before you act.